Corpus: 543,223 opinions ·
3,177 judges ·
newest 2026-06-23 · expanding
Coverage ↗
Opinion
govinfo:USCOURTS-flsd-1_25-cv-25486-0
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA MIAMI DIVISION CASE NO.: 1:25-cv-25486-MOM NO& 'Angelo GLITCH PRODUCTIONS PTY LTD, Plaintiff, THE PARTNERSHIPS and UNINCORPORATED ASSOCIXTIONS IDENTIFIED ON SCHEDULE ç$A,'' Defendants. / ORDER GM NTING PLAINTIFF'S M OTION FOR PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION ORDER THIS CAUSE is before the Court upon Plaintiff Glitch Productions Pty Ltd's (Cûplaintiff ' or (tGlitch'') Motiqn for Entl-y of a Preliminary Injunction. ECF No. (171 . In the Motion, Glitch seeks entl'y of a preliminal-y injunction order against the Partnerships and Unincorporated Associations Identified on Schedule A hereto (collectively, GsDefendants'), and ently of an order restraining the financial accounts used by Defendants, pursuant to the Lallham Act, 15 U.S.C. jj 1 1 16 et seq.k Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 65; the Copyright Act, The Coul't previously entered an order granting Plaintiff s ex parte Motion for Entl'y of Temporary Restraining Order (CtTRO''). ECF No. (1 11. The Cou14 convened a public hearing on May 14, 2026. See ECF No. (221. Plaintiff certifies that it served Defend, ants notice of this hearing on May 5, 2026. See ECF No. (23j. Only counsel for Plaintiff appeared throtlgh counsel at the hearing on the Motion. As represented by Plaintiff's counsel at the hearing and retlected on the docket of this case, no Case 1:25-cv-25486-FAM Document 28 Entered on FLSD Docket 05/22/2026 Page 1 of 22 . ,' . '' cti ted an ihtention to challenge the TRO, or otherFisçDefendants have made any appearânce, in ca . . ' ' . . ' . . ct and/or defended against the. Complainty' Yl'ke Co' ùrt heard argument frqm Plaintiff andanswere . ' , . . . . ' . .. . . . . ' . .' . . . . . .L ' . reviewed the evidence that Plaintiff's counsel presented to the Court. Uptln due consideration of tlie Motlon, the pel4in'erkt portions of the record, thç relevant ' . . ' J authorities, and for the reasons set fol-th herein, the Motion is hereby GIRANTED. . ' ' ' ' '' è ( FACTUAL BACKGROUND l . * ' The following background is taken.from Plaintiff's Complaint, ECF No. (1j, tlie Motion, and supporting evidentiary submissions and exhibits. Glitch ij the owner of vayious copyright yègistrations related to its Mvrder Dropes frbnchljé ' . . (the CIMD Copyrighted Work, s''). A list of the MD Copyrighted Works is below. See ECF No. (8- 1 (1 . . . . . , . - . . , ' . , . . . . ; ' g . J I-T.s. copvriaht w ork Title Issue Date Re .' No. ' . VA0002392355 Murder Drones logo. Febnzary 15, 2024 VA0002392949 . ' Cyn. February 15, 2024 VA0002392950 J. February 15, 2024 VA0002392951 N. FebHav 15, 2024 VA0002392952 Uzl. February 15, 2024 V40002392953 V. February 15, 2024 Glitch also owns the followingfederally registered trademarks, which are valid and. registered on the Principal Register of the United States Patent and Trademark Office (the GCMD . Trademarks''). See id. Case 1:25-cv-25486-FAM Document 28 Entered on FLSD Docket 05/22/2026 Page 2 of 22 Rezistration RezistrationTrademark Goods and ServicesNumber Dqte For: Clothing, pamely, shorts, nantj. coats. dresses, skirts' and socks; footwear; headWear; t- shirts; printed t-shirts; shirts; bandanas, namely, neckerchiefsi. shorts; hooded kweatshirts; jumpers, nalnely, p'ullovers; jumpers in the natuï'e of sweaters; singlets', sweatbands; wristbands as clothing; hats in class 025. For: Action toys, namely, actiçn figure toys; children's toys, namçly, stuffed toys; costumes for toy's namely, doll costulnes;) cuddly toys, namely, plush dolls; electronic children'â multi'ple activity tqys; molded plastic toy figurines; .scale model toy figures; toy models', plastic toys, namely, toy figures; plush ioys; plush stuffed toys; scale model kits; toys,7 ,082,519 MURDER DRONES Jun. 20, 2023 namely, dolls; electronic games apparattls adapted for use with ail extelmal display scréen or monitor; dice gannes; arcade game lnachines; gaming machines', games, namely, arcade game machines, action target games, board games and card games; electronic games for teaching children; pa14y games', portable gaming devices, namely, pol4able video game consoles', trading cards for games; dolls; plush dolls in class 028. For: Arranging of entertailunent, namely, arranging and conducting social entel-tainment events', entel-tainment, namely, live show perfonnances featuring video animation', fan club services for entertaimuent; live entel-tainment, 3 Case 1:25-cv-25486-FAM Document 28 Entered on FLSD Docket 05/22/2026 Page 3 of 22 ' namely, live audio per'formances by actors', live eritel-tainme' nt production services, namely, live audio performaùceà by actor; organisation of competitions, namely, entertainperg and educational services in the nàtkire éf competitions in the field of entertainment,'educatiort pulture, spol4s, and other pon-business and nbn-commercial fields; arranginj of contestp; organisatioh of entel-tainment eventï in the nature of live musical perforniances; roduction of audio entertainm'ent,P namely, pmduction t)f audio l'ecordings; pmduction otvideo ' podcasts', jroduction of likç entel-tainment, namely, prodtlciion of television shows? plays; provision of online non- dolnlogdable audio apd video ' . ' j%entertaimrent in the néiule o visual and audio wcordingq featuring animated pontent via electronic or digital transmission; provision of online rion- downloadable audio and video entel4ainment in the nature of visual and audio reçordings featuring animated entertaimnent; television entertainment in the nature of ongoing television programs in the field of variety; video entel-taimuent services, namely, providing a web site featuring video presentations featuring animations; providing online information in the tield of entertainment; providing online videos, not downloadable, in the field of animations; film production selwices, other than advertising films; production of animated cartoons; providing online electronic ublications, not 4 Case 1:25-cv-25486-FAM Document 28 Entered on FLSD Docket 05/22/2026 Page 4 of 22 ' downtoadable, nqmely, newsletters in the field of animation( entel-tainl-nent; electlrnic publication of informatipn on a wide ranje of topics, inclktding online and over a global eonïputer nètwork, namqly, publishing of electronic publications; pub.lisbing of electronic publications; screenplay writing; production of webcasts, other than advel-tising, namely, providing webcasts in the field of anilnation entel-tainment; online publication of journals or diaries consisting of weblog and blog services in the nature of online joulmals, namely, blogs ' featuring animation entertainlnent in class 041 . For: Al4icles of imitation jewellery, naluely, imitation' , - - . , necklaces and imitatibn bràcelets; . Imitation jewellely; Imitation ' jewellery ornaments, namely, ilnitation necklaces and iluitation bracelets', Pins being jewellery; ' Decorative pins being jewellely; Decorative pins of precious metal being jewellery; Charms of semi- prècious metals for jewellery; Fake ' jewellery, namely, imitation jewellery and plastic jewellel-y; 7,510,567 MURDER DRONES Sep. 24, 2024 Bracelets being jewellel-y; Clocks; Decorative articles for personal use, namely, jewellely; Decorative ornaments made of plated precious metals, namely, jewellery plated with precious metals', Earrings', Ear studs', Figtlrines coated with precious metal, namely, medals coated with precious metals; Hat jewellery', Lanyards for holding keys; Necklaces; Key chains; Key rings connprised of split rings with decorative fobs or trinkets; Key holders bein ke rin s; Charms . g Case 1:25-cv-25486-FAM Document 28 Entered on FLSD Docket 05/22/2026 Page 5 of 22 for key rings; JeFellery rings; Watches in class 14. . ) ' For: Lanyards for holding papey cafds, nàmely, lanyards for name ' badge holders; Printed artworks, nalnely, graphic art printî; Printed pojtefs; Mounted printed postéts; Printed advel-tising posters; Printed publications, namely, books, hand- outs, and workbooks in the field of graphic design; Printed comic books; Printed manga comic ' books; Printed picture books; Printed stoly books; Cartoon prints; Printed magaéines featuring cal-toon characters; Animation cels; Badges made of paper; Printed stickers being stationery stickers', Stationel in class 0 16. Gliteh alleges that Defendants, through fully interactive, e-commerce storesl , operating under the seller aliases identified on Schedule A to the Complaint and attached hereto (the dsseller Aliases''), have advertised, promoted, offered for sale, sold, or impol-ted goods bearing and/or embodying what Glitch has determined to be counterfeits, infringements, reproductions, or colorable imitations of the MD Trademarks and/or unauthorized copies of the MD Copyrighted Works. ECF No. (11. Glitch alleges that it has not licensed or authorized Defendants to use any of the MD Trademarks or MD Copyrighted W orks, and none of the Defendants are authorized retailers èf genuine Glitch Products. See ECF No. (8-1) ! 21 . Glitch attests that it investigated the promotion and sale of infringing and counterfeit versions of its branded products by Defendants (Ccunauthorized Products''). See id. at ! 19. Glitch l The e-commerce store URLS are listed on Schedule A to the Complaint and attached hereto. Case 1:25-cv-25486-FAM Document 28 Entered on FLSD Docket 05/22/2026 Page 6 of 22 alleges that it analyzed each of the e-commerce stol'es operating under the Seller Aliases and determined that Unauthorized Prodtlcts were being offered for sale to residents of the United States, including Florida. 1cl ln addition, each e-commerce store offered shipping to Florida. 1d. Glitch attests that it conducted a review and visually inspected the Unauthorized Products liited for sale on each Defendants' e-commerce store and deterlnined said products were non-genuine and unauthorized by Glitch. 1d. 1I. LEGAL STANDARD To obtain a preliminal'y injunction, a party must demonstrate'. (1) a substantial likelihood of success on the merits; (2) that irreparable injury will be iuffered if the relief is not granted; (3) that the threatened injuly outweighs the harm the relief Fould inflict on the non-movant; and (4.) that the entry of the relief would serve the pubiic interest. Schiavo ex rp/. Schindler v. Schiavo, 51 F.3d 982, 985 (1 lth Cir. 1 995) (applying the test to a preliminal-y injunction in a Lanham Act case). 111. CONCLUSIONS OF LAW Glitch's Motion supports the following conclusions of law: Glitch has a strong probability of proving at trial that consumers are likely to be confused by Defendants' advel-tisement, promotion, sale, offer for sale, and/or distribution of Unauthorized Products, and that Defendants' Unauthorized Products use infringing and countelfeit versions of the MD Trademarks and/or unauthorized copies of the MD Copyrighted Works. B. This Cou14 has personal jurisdiction over Defendants because Defendants directly target their business activities toward consumers in the United States, including Florida. Case 1:25-cv-25486-FAM Document 28 Entered on FLSD Docket 05/22/2026 Page 7 of 22 Specifically, Defendants have targeted sales to Florida residçnts by setting up and operating e-commerce stores that target United States consumers using the Seller Aliases, offer shipping to Florida, and/or have sold Unauthorized Products to residents of Florida. Because of the infringement of the MD Trademarks and/or MD Copyyighted Works, Glitch is likely to suffer imluediate and il-reparable i. njury if a preliminary injunction order is not granted. The following specific facts, as set forth in Glitch's Complaint, Glitch's Motion, and acqompanying declarations, demonstrate that ilnmediate and irreparable loss, damage, and injury will result to Glitch and to consumers before Defendants can be heard in opposition unless Glitch's request for preliminal-y relief is granted: Defendants own, operate, and/or control fully interactive, e-commerce stores operating under the Seller Aliases which advellise, offer for sale, sell, and ship Unauthorized Prodtlcts to customers in Florida that bear infringing and/or counterfeit versions of the MD Trademarks and/or bear tlnauthorized copies of the MD Copyrighted Works; and There is good cause to believe that more counterfeit and infringing products bearing the MD Trademarks and/or unauthorized copies of the MD Copyrighted Works will appear in the lnarketplace; that .consumers are likely to be misled, confused, and éisappointed by the quality of the Unauthorized Products', and that Glitch may suffer loss of sales for its gentline prodtlcts and an unnatural erosion of the legitiluate marketplace in which it operates', and Case 1:25-cv-25486-FAM Document 28 Entered on FLSD Docket 05/22/2026 Page 8 of 22 The potential harm to Defendants in restraining their trade in counterfeit and infringipg . . ' goods through their e-cormperce stores and freezing ill-gotten profits if a preliminar'y injunction order is granted is far otltweighed by the in'eparable harm Glitch?. its reputation, and its goodwill has suffered and will continue to suffer if a preliminary injunction order is not issued. The public interest favors issuance of the preliminal-y injunction order to prevent consumer confusion and dispel the false impression that Defendants are operating their e-commerce stores with Glitch's approval and endoà-sement, as wqll as protect Glitch's legitimate intellectual property interests. Further, the public will be protected from being defrauded by the illegal sale of Unauthorized Products. Under 1 5 U.S.C. j 1 1 17(a), Glitch may be entitled tp recover, as an equitable remedy, the illegal profits gained through Defend.ants' distribution aln:d sales of goods bearing infringing and/or cotlnterfeit versions of the MD Trademarks. See Reebok Int'l, L td. v. Marnatech Enters., Inc., 970 F.2d 552, 559 (9th Cir. 1992) (quoting Fuller Brush Prods. Co. v. Fuller frt/s'/c Co., 299 F.2d 772, 777 (7th Cir. 1962)) ((ûAn accounting of profits under j 1 1 17(a) is not synonymous with an award of monetary daluages: & gajn accounting for profits . . . is an equitable remedy subject to the principles of equity'''). Under 17 U.S.C. j 504(b) and 17 U.S.C. j 502(a), Olitch may be entitled to recover, as an equitable remedy, the illegal profits gained tlu'ough Defendants' distribution and sales of goods bearing unatlthorized copies of the MD Copyrighted W orks. See Antsy Labs, LLC v. lndividuals, 24-cv-61436-WPD, 2024 WL 4472009, at *2 (S.D. Fla. Sept. 16, 2024) (tûunder 17 U.S. Code j 504(b) and 17 U.S. Code j 502(a), Plaintiff may be Case 1:25-cv-25486-FAM Document 28 Entered on FLSD Docket 05/22/2026 Page 9 of 22 entitled to recover, as an eqtlitable remedy, the illegalprofits gained through Defendants' distribution and sales of goods infringing Plaintiff s Copyrights.''). Reqtlesting eqtlitable relief ttinvokes the district court's inherent equitable powers to order preliminal'y relief, including an asset freeze, in order to assure the availability of . . J permanent relief.'' f evi uv/rlî/.5'qç & Co., 51 F.3, d at 987 (citing Federal FFAJJC (abrogated on other groundsp). In light of the inherently deceptive nattlre of the intellectual property infringement business, and the likelihood that Defendants have violated federal trademark and . 'd copyright laws, Glitch has good reajon to believe Defendants will hide or transfer their ill-gotten assets beyond the jtlrisdiction of this Court unless those assets are restrained. Accordingly, upon due consideration of Glitch's Colpplaint, the Motion, the supportipg evidentiary submissions, the relevant authol-ities, and for the reasons set forth on the record at the hearing on the Motion, which are incorporated herein, it is hereby ORDERED AND ADJUDGED that the Motion, ECF No. g17q, is GRANTED, under the terms set fol'th below: Defendants, their affiliates, officers, agents, servants, employees, attorneys, confederates, and a11 persons acting for, with, by, tlu'ough, under, or in active concert with Defendants be preliminaly enj oined and restrained from: a. using the MD Trademarks or any reproductions, counterfeit copies, or colorable imitations thereof in any manner in connection with the distl-ibution, marketing, advel4ising, offering for sale, or sale of any product that is not a genuine Glitch product or not authorized by Glitch to be sold in colmection with the MD Trademarks; Case 1:25-cv-25486-FAM Document 28 Entered on FLSD Docket 05/22/2026 Page 10 of 22 b. reprodueing, distribtlting copies of, making deyivative works of, or publicly displaying the MD Copyrighted Works in any manner without the express authorization of Glitch; passing off, inducing, or enabling others to sell or pass off any product as a genuine Glitch product or any other product produced by Glitch, that is not Glitqh'y o!- not produced under the atlthorization, control, or supelwision of Glitch and approved by . , ' , Glitch for sale under the MD Trademarks and/or MD Copyrighted Works; d. committing any acts calculAted to cause consumers to believe that Defendants' products are those sold under the authorization, control, or supervision of Glitch, or are sponsored by, approved by, or otherwise connected with Glitch; further infringing the MD Trademarksand MD Copyrighted .W orks and dqmaging Glitch's goodwill; and f. mantlfacturing, shipping, delivering, holding for sale, transfen-ing or otherwise mpving, , . 1. ' storing, distributing, returning, or otherwise disposing of, in any manner, products or inventory not manufactured by or for Glitch, nor authorized by Glitch to be sold or offered for sale, and which bear any of Glitch's tradel-narks, including the MD Trademarlts, or any l'eproductions, cotmterfeit copies, o1' colorable imitations and/or which bear the MD Copyrighted W orks. Upon Glitch's request, any third pa14y with actual notice of this Order who is providing services for any of the Defendants, or in connection with any of Defendants' Seller Aliases, including, without limitation, any online platforms such AliExpress.com ttlAliExpl'ess''l Alipay, Amazon.com, lnc. tlûAmazolz''l5 . . 1 Amazon Pay, Dhgate.com (((DHGate'') eBay, Inc. (1CeBay'') Roadget Business PTE Ltd. IGCSHEIN''I Walmart, lnc. (1ûWalmart''), and Context Logic, Inc. d/b/a Wish.com (t$Wish'') (collectively, the (G-fhird Case 1:25-cv-25486-FAM Document 28 Entered on FLSD Docket 05/22/2026 Page 11 of 22 Pa14y Pfoviders'') shall, within seven (7) calendar days afler receipt of such notice, provide to Glitch expedited discovely, inclqding copies of al1 documents and rçcords in such person's or entity's possession or control relating to: r.. the identities and locations of Defendants, their aftiliates, officers, agçnts, jervants, eluployees, confederates, attolmeys, and any persons acting in concert .or participatioq with them, including all known contact information and atl associated e-mail addresses; the nature of Defendants' operations and a11 associated sales, methods of payment for services, and tinancial information, including, without limitation, identifying infonuation associated with the Seller Aliases and Defendants' financial accounts? as well as providing a full accounting of Defendants' sales and listing history related to their respective Seller Aliases; and c. any financial accotlnts owned or controlled by Defendants, including their agents, servants, employees, confederates, attolmeys, and any persons acting in concel't or participation with them, including sklqh accotlnts residing with or under the control of any banks, savings and loan associations, payment processors or other financial instittltions, including, without limitation, the AliExpress, Alipay, Amazon, Amazon Pay, Dl-lGate, eBay, Payoneel' Global, lnc. (tûpayoneer'') Paypal, lnc. (($PayPa1'')) l SHEIN, Stripe, lnc. ($CStripe''), Walmal't, and Wish, or other merchant account providers, payment providers, third pal4y processors, and credit card associations (e.g., Mastercard and VISA). Upon Glitch's request, those with notice of this Order, including the Third Pal4y Providers as defined in Paragraph 2, shall within seven (7) calendar days after receipt of such notice, disable and cease displaying any advertiseluents used by or associated with Defendants in Case 1:25-cv-25486-FAM Document 28 Entered on FLSD Docket 05/22/2026 Page 12 of 22 connection with the sale of counterfeit and infringing goods using the MD Trademarks and/or which bear the MD Copyrighted Works. Defendants shall be temporarily and preliminarily restrained and enjoined from transferring or d. isposing of any money or other of Defepdants' assets until ftèrther ordered by this Court. Any Third Pgrty Providers, including AliExpress, Alipay, Amazon, Amazon Pay, Dl-lGate, eBay, Payoneer, Paypal, SHEIN,Stripe, Walmal-t, and Wishshall, within seven (7) calendar days of receipt of this Order'. locate a1l accounts and funds colmected to Defendants' Seller Aliases, including, but $) not limited to, any financial accounts connected to the information listed in Schçdule A hereto, the e-mail addresses idwltified in Exhibit 3 to the Declaration of Andrew . ',, . . . . Masterson, and any e-mail addresses provided for Defendants by third parties; and b. restrain and enjoin any such accounts or fttnds from transferring or disposing of any money or other of Defendants' assets tlntil ful-ther order by this Court. Glitch is authorized to issue expedited written discovery to Defendants, pursuant to Federal Rules of Civil Procedure 33, 34, and 36, related to: a. the identities and locations of Defendants, their affiliates, officers, agents, servants, employees, confederates, attorneys, and any persons acting in active concert or participation with them, including a11 known contact information, including any and al1 associated e-mail addressess' and the nature of Defendants' operations and a11 associated sales, methods of paylnent for services, and financial infonuation, including, without limitation, identifying information associated with the Seller Aliases and Defendants' financial accotlnts, as Case 1:25-cv-25486-FAM Document 28 Entered on FLSD Docket 05/22/2026 Page 13 of 22 well as providing full accounting of Defendants' sales and listing histol'y related to their respective Seller Aliases. Glitch is authorized to issue the expedited discovery requests authorized in Paragraph 6 via e-mail. Defendants shall respond to any such discovery requests within three (3) business days of being served via e-mail. Any Defendants that are subject to this Order may appear and move to dissolve or modify the Order as penuitted by and in compliance with the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure and Southelm District of Florida Local Rules. The ten-thousand-dollar ($10,000) bond posted by Plaintiff shalt remain with the Cou14 8. until a final disposition of this case or tmtil the Preliminal-y Injtmction is terminated. . # DONE AND ORDERED in Chambers at Miami, Florida, ol . - , 2026. x M .A * .A . JM M FEDEP ' A. MORENOUNITED STATES DISTRICT JUDGE 14 Case 1:25-cv-25486-FAM Document 28 Entered on FLSD Docket 05/22/2026 Page 14 of 22 Glitch Productions Pty Ltd v. The Partnerships and Unincorporated Associations Identified on Schedule IIA'' - Case No. 25-cv-25486LM OltENO/D'Angel0 Schedule A lnfl-ingement ' ' N0. Seller Alias T e URL . https://- .amazop.qoe sp?ie=uTF8&selle I'=AZCVFR3YB8IGGH&aSin=BODV3LXI 1 Chaoli Wei Trademark onl YN ' ' https://- .annazon.com/sp?ie=uTF8&selle 2 HGSJKVWQWSZ Trademark on1 NAIGXP6WSGDW JL ' https://- .dhgate.coe stpre/top- 3 faroe Trademark on1 sellin /22033709.1:t1111 ' . hups://us.shein.com/stol'e/holre?store-code= 4 a lebnanan Trademark onl 8053028537 ' https://us.slaein.com/stol'e/home?store-codev 5 Bluesk ,C0465 Trademark onl 7469357952 lnûps://us.shein.com/store/home?stol'e code= . - - 6 cds z Trademark onl ' 2470'094712 . https://tls.sheila.coe store/holne?store- code= 7 dBGh b Trademark on1 3694435713 https://us.shein.com/store/holue?store- code= 8 Di Mu Rui Tradeluark on1 ' '43 19837955 . https://us.slnein.com/stol'e/honae?stol'e code- 9 dsvdsds Trademark on1 ' 7912427471 . hups://us.slaeill.coe stol'e/home?store code= 10 uan zhouxian eke'i Trademark onl 1948650346 h/ps://us.shein.com/stol'e/home?store- code= 1 1 'ian umin Tradeluark onl ' 120 1266755 https://us.shein.com/stol'e/home?stol'e- code= 12 NFSVFNB Trademark onl 5273492590 htps://us.sheilA.com/stol'e/home?store- code= 13 sf f Trademark on1 1459622506 la/psr//us.shein.com/stol'e/holue?store- coder 14 Tasvc Trademark on1 8763414753 hûps://us.slnein.com/stol-e/home?stol'e code= 15 Uni ue St le Trademark oill 5299914293 https://us.shein.colr/stol'e/iaome?store code= 16 Zhi ianz Trademark onl 44 1 87463 15 https://us.shein.colNstol'e/lAome?store code= 17 ZYSMNL Trademark onl 7754575226 lalps://- .walmartacoe global/seller/loz7 18 Evau eline Trademark on1 71662 hûps://- .walmart.coe global/seller/loz8 19 JQ OMMICE Trademark on1 8063 1 Case 1:25-cv-25486-FAM Document 28 Entered on FLSD Docket 05/22/2026 Page 15 of 22 . . . . ' . ' ' # ' ' . p . . ' ' l . .' , .. . r. . . . . : ' ' d . ' '. . . . ; . 1 .. . .. , . . . . ! , . . ' ' . . . . hlps://- .walmal4.coe globàl/seller/lozg' 20 ShaoFen Mei Trademark onl . ' 03653 ' . ' ' ' . hups://v .walmah.coe global/seller/loz7 . 21 UCCI Store Trademark on1 ' 06498 . . . . ' https://- .walmrt.càe global/seller/lozg 22 ' on on ke'i Trademark on1 . . . ' 17505 ' ' . ' . hûps://- .amazon.coo sp?ie=uTF8&srlle . h .23 bfhrdc Co ri ht on1 . i=AZXZZCINKJOYIJ . : .. . . : : .. '. https://- .amazon.com/sp?ie=uTF8&selle. 24 WZMPA Co ri ht on1 ' r=A1L61U2OH9TLC3 . htlpsr//www.dhgate com/store/top-' . :25 beneon Co ri ht on1 . sellin /22033795.14t11 . . . . ' . . ' ' https://- .dhgate.coe stpre/top- . 26 fashion trendll 1 Co ri ht onl sellin /22042369.11tm1 ' ' ' . hups://- .dlagate.cpe store/top-. 27 reensboro Co ri ht on1 sellin /22027875.13tm1 ' https://- .dhgate.coe store/top- .. ' '''' - ''' . 28 to wan '08 Co ri ht on1 sellin /22255850;11tm1 . https://us.shein.coe store/home?store- code= 29 Cadadiaes sudadera Co ri ht on1 9721389501 . htps://us.shein.com/store/home?stôre- code- . 30 GTGNGFHBNH Co ri ht on1 ' 1530284558 ' ' . ' . . htps://us.shein.com/store/home?störe- code- 31 ln erpa Co ri ht on1 2396492779 https://us.shein.colNgtoreiome?store code- 32 Kaze Anime Store Co ri ht on1 . . ' 46391 18323 ' ' ' . . https://us.shein.com/store/home?störe-code- 33 Lew Co ri ht on1 ' 5031903252 '' ' ' PulseWear h/ps://us.shein.coe store/home?store- code= 34 Breez Tees Co ri ht on1 7214568573 ' j. '' ' htt s://us.shein.com/store/holne?store code=. P - 35 redfh Co ri ht on1 ' 5568432480 ' '. ' hapst//us.shein.com/store/home?store-code= 36 llmvem Co ri ht on1 9553769905 . htps://us.shein.cop/store/home?store-code=' SALENX Co ri ht on1 211281662937 htps://us.shein.coe store/home?store-code= 38 Sarai . Co . ri ht on1 3673785604 ' . htps://us.shein.coe storelome?store code=.. 39 Wan ian iansho Co ri ht on1 8369107697 ' ' L ' ' htps://us.shein.coe store/home?store code= . * 40 whbdn6320 Co ri ht on1 . 2223560446 ' , . . https:// us.shein.cpm/store/home?storè-code= . 41 WWEFXJ Co ii ht on1 4777982380 htps://us.shein.coe store/home?store-code= 42 Zolzkua SHOP Co right on1 5095240675 16 . ' . . Case 1:25-cv-25486-FAM Document 28 Entered on FLSD Docket 05/22/2026 Page 16 of 22 https://- .walmal't.coliglobal/sellel'/l 029 43 cai an Co ri ht onl 12406 enchenkejiyouxiango hups://- .walmal4.cooglobal/sellel'/l 028 44 n si Co ri ht onl 62308 ' https://- .wallnart.coe global/seller/loz6 45 Euiuw Co ri ht onl 14141 laûps://- .walmal4.coH global/sellel'/loz8 46 Evel da Trove Co ri ht on1 93128 hdpsi//- .walmart.côe global/sellel'/l 029 47 Fluff Life.Goods Co ri ht onl 05590 lAttps://- .wallnal4.com/global/sellel'/l 025 48 Good Nei hbor Sho Co ri ht on1 06409 hlps://- .walmal4.colNglobal/sellel'/l 0 1 6 49 Hen un Co ri ht on1 86432 lAlps://- .walmal4.com/global/seller/loz8 50 Hertha Co ri ht on1 99959 htps://- .wallnad.coo global/sellel-/l 028 51 Jillian Aloma Co ri ht onl 60701 lzttps://- .walmal4.com/global/seller/loz6 52 Joniuo Co ri ht on1 14 14 1 53 DISMISSED , liuyangshiyiyingfubai https://- .walma/.coln/global/jeller/loz; 54 huo Co ri ht on1 69461 https://- .walma/.coxglobàl/sellel'/lozg 55 Love Sho e Co ri ht on1 65463 htps://- .walmal4.collglobal/seller/loz8 56 Loveah Martinez Co ri ht on1 . . 47 187 lushanshiyuhuajiafan htps://- .walma/.com/global/sellel'/lozg 57 ouxian Co ri ht on1 02835 58 DISMISSED lattps://- .wallna/.coliglobal/sellel'/loz8 59 mlmw Co ri ht onl 3486 1 https://- .walmal4.colu/global/sellel'/loz7 60 anda dundtln Co ri ht on1 9 1829 https://- .walmal.colNglobal/seller/loz8 61 suo Co ri ht on1 79987 https://- .walmaM.coH global/sellel'/l 029 62 WeiW eiliachan Co ri ht onl 02576 https://- .wallnal-t.coe global/sellel'/lo 10 63 WY Co ri ht on1 77995 https://- .walmal4.com/global/sellel'/loz8 64 xixit oh Co ri ht on1 84666 htps://- .wallral't.coo global/seller/l 028 65 Zhan Xue Co ri ht on1 98301 17 Case 1:25-cv-25486-FAM Document 28 Entered on FLSD Docket 05/22/2026 Page 17 of 22 , . ' . ' ' .. '' ' j ' r . frog building block . : . https://e .wish.com/merchant/6l67bofez6 66 house 1 Co' ri ht onl , 13628861+8289 ' . Trademark and https://- .aliexpressrcom/stol'e/l 10448530 67 CYF Home 017 Store Co ri ht ' ' 8 ' . Tradeluark and https://- .aliexpress.com/store/l 103621 13 68 F1 ih Life Store Co ri ht ' ' 9 ' ' ' ' ' Shopl 104002467 Trademark and https://- .aliexpress.coe storp/l 10400246 69 Store Co ri ht 8 Shopl 104064882 Trademark and https://- .aliexprejsycom/store/.l 10405594 70 Store Co ri ht . 2 Shopl 104078171 Trademark and hdps://- .aliexpress.com/store/llo4o86o3 i gtor'e Co ri ht . 17 ' 5110p1104676622 Trademark and httpà://- .aliexprrjs.com/stor'q/lJlo46766z 72 Stbre Co ri ht . 2 . Shopl 104717050 Trademark and https://- .qliexpress,c.qe store/llo47z3oo 73 Store Co ri ht 4 . ' . ' XinTreasure Poster Trademark and https://- .aliexpress.coe store' /1 10439200 74 Store Co ri ht 4 . . Trademark and https://- .amazon.coe sp?ie=uTF8&selle 75 Duoliu Co ri ht r=A2VX2N30CORH4Y tiexiquyongshangsha Trademark and https://- .amazon.coo sp?ie=uTF8&selle 16 n mao ouxian on si Co ri ht . . r=AI.O4L4B1tRWYZT'/ . . Xia men di xiang gao ' ' shan' g mao you xian Trademark and https://- .amazon.coe sp?ie=uTF8&selle 77 on si Co ri ht NAK34UZUZCNITV Xiamen Jianpi Tao E- Trademark and https://- .amazon.coo sp?ie=uYF8&selle 78 commerce Co., Ltd. Co ri ht NAI6CLXKPMUOUYI xiamenbazishangmao Trademark and hlps://- .amazon.coo sp?ie=uTF8&selle 79 . ouxian on si ' Co ri ht ' 1=AE2GX56IRDA3D . ' Trademai'k and ' https://- .dhgate.coe stol'e/top- . 80 d111102209467 Co ri ht ' ' sellin /22022470.htm1 ' Trademark and https://- .dhgate.com/store/top- 81 iftsho ' cn Co ri ht sellin /22242688.11tm1 Trademark and . 82 . 770mmc . Co ri ht . htt s://www.eba .com/str/the 1obalsa1es770 Trademark and ' 83 . abdellatifco Co ri ht htt s://www.ebq .com/str/ oldenhstore Tràdemark and 84 avocadozol'3 Co ri ht htt s://Www.eba .com/str/avocadozol3? T d k d. ra emar an 85 difa 56 Co ri ht htt s://www.eba .com/str/mbtlzzstore Trademark and ' 86 elkadi @. Co ri ht htt s://www.eba .coln/str/da istore handanshinaxisiwang Trademark and https://- .ebay.coe sir/handanshinaxisiw 87 luo-o Co ri ht an luoo? 18 Case 1:25-cv-25486-FAM Document 28 Entered on FLSD Docket 05/22/2026 Page 18 of 22 . , .. . r, . Trad, èmark and . . . . . . . J88 . mOt1ata1234 ' Co ri ht ,. ' ntt s://www.eba .com/str/moflatalz34 Yodemark and 89 . mrsolll Co ri ht htt s://www.eba .bom/usr/mfholll ' Trademalk and . ' . ' 90 norohen 34 Co !'i ht ht't s://www.eba .corn/str/winmarius? . ' Trademark and ' 91 online store 84 Co ri ht htt s://www.eba .com/str/tarustore? Trademark and . . 92 or.sroulvich Co ri ht htt s://www.eba .com/str/the 1oba1sa1es247 Trademark and ' 93 ori ad4 Co ri ht . htt s://www.eba .com/str/ori ad4 ' . ' Trademark and . ' .' 94 er 48 Co ri ht htt s://www.eba .com/str/wiststore . . Trademark and ' 95 hbako Co ri ht htt s://www.eba .com/usr/ hbako? sichuanhanfangbuil-g Tradepark and https://- .ebay.cox str/sichuaA rfrgbui 96 4 Co ii ht ' ' 194 ' ' Trademark and 97 tone3015 Co ri ht htt s://www.eba .com/str/markbrener ' Trademark and . 98 weranaha Co ri ht . htt j://www.eba .com/str/ artdeèor? Trqdemark and ' t 99 malla Co ri ht htt s://wWw.eba .com/str/thouse oster Trademark and . . ' kt4 C i ht htt s://www.eba .com/str/ onatanbest100 onful o r Tr>demark and ' 101 Cloudteesdesi n Co ri ht htt ' s://www.cloudteesdesi ù.corn/ Trademark and 102 PM npresent Co ri ht . htt s:// art n resent.sho / . Trademark ànd ' ' 103 Sm1 Mucos.com Co ri ht htt s://san mucos.com/ Trademark and hûps://us.shein.com/store/home?store- code= 104 . axcdf v mldtm Co ri ht 4062605094 Trademark and hdps://ut.shein.coe store/home?stgre- code= 105 .Bei in un Co ri ht 9741402618 Trademark and https://us.shein.coe stpre/home?stol'e codeQ . 106 . c bh u . Co ri 'ht . 8416358099 . . ' Trademark an' d hûps://vs,shein.com/store/home?stoyb- code= .107 . . d dsh d Co ri ht 761 1 123424 Trademark and https://us.shein.coe store/home?store- code= 108 . fd n d Co ri ht 1060657515 . Trademark and https://us.shein.coo store/home?store- code=' . ( ,: 109 df hi Co ri ht 837 .6419370 Trademark and hûps://us.shein.com/store/home?store-code=. 110 GUOHUA T SHIRT Oo yright ' 6023100670 19 Case 1:25-cv-25486-FAM Document 28 Entered on FLSD Docket 05/22/2026 Page 19 of 22 . . . . . ' . . : Trademark ànd https://us.shdiù.conï/stor' e/hprhe?stofèicode= 111 fla . PawsCo454 Co ri ht ' . 8919974468 . .. . ' . Trademark and hljë://ps.shein.coestore/ome?stofexcodeli 12 , huan 'unmin 77 . Co ri ht . . . 39268302t5 . ,' . y ' Trademark and hlps://tls.sheih'.eom/àtore/home?store ' codeo . ' '''''* ' 113 aifen 1ou . Co ri ht . ' . 1280690625 . ' htps://us.shein.com/store/home?store- 's code= Trademark and 2292313163&ici=PageGoodsDejai1&main c. l 14 Luck Da C0454 Co ri ht ate id=1974&main ocids 1d=171393834 . Trademark and https://us.shein.coo store/home?stgqewcode= 1 15 Qixiaa Co ri ht ' 6638834712 Trademark and ' https://us.shein.coe stol'e/home?store- code= . 1t6 TruffleTides Co ri ht 8127740589 Trademark ànd hûps://us.sheih.coe stol'e/home?store-code= . 1 17 VanillavoW4s Co ri ht 6022250328 . ' ' ' . Trademark and httpj://us.shein.coe store/home?store codel . 1 18 WE BGVGHYHU Co ri ht . 4651701037 - Trademark and hups://ùj.shein.eoe store/hometstöre-code= . 1 19 Zitizen34 . Co ri ht . 6365019783 . . ' Trademark and htps://- .walmad.coe global/sellèr/loz8 120 xiaoweixiaodian Co ri ht . 72287 . . ' . ' . Trademark ahd hdps://- .walmah.coo global/seller/loz8 ' 121 CC Valle Co ri ht . 80164 ' : Trademark and htps://v .waimal.com/global/seller/loz7. 122 binshanshan mao Co ri ht ' 67154 ' '. Trademark and hlps://- .walmal.coW global/sellef/loz7 123 ' boxuan store Co ri ht 76725 . . ' 124 DISMISSED . Trademark and https://- .waimah.coe global/seller/lozg 125 Christina Galla her Uo ri ht 12083 . Trademark and https://- .walma/.coo global/sellel'/loz; 126 chuanhuasho Co ri ht 98456 . ' ' ' Tradeniark and hdps://- .walmal,coWglobal/seller/loz; ' 127 D&X Co ri ht 50900 . . Trademark and htps://- .walmad.coo global/seller/lol6 128 DGSJHSFSGS Co ri ht 59057 129 DISMISSED . ' . Trademark and htps://- .walmal4.coW global/seller/loz8 130 f Duo Duo Doll Co ri ht 65756 , Trademark and https://- .walmad'.coo globallseller/loz8 131 Eas Sho De ot Co ri ht 98352 7 Trademark and https://- .walmrt.coH global/seller/loz7 132 FDGHJHGKUJ Co ri ht ' 79582 Trademark a' nd hdps://- .walmaM.coe global/seller/loz7 . ' 133 fs s s ds Co ri ht 60464 20 Case 1:25-cv-25486-FAM Document 28 Entered on FLSD Docket 05/22/2026 Page 20 of 22 Trademérk and https://- .walmart.com/global/seller/loz8 134 Fuseerich do ri ht ' ' 03144 Trademark and hûps://- .wallual4.colr/global/seller/loz8 135 Globesur rise Hub Co ri ht 90778 136 DISMISSED Trademark and lattps://- .walmal4.coe global/sellel'/loz8 137 uofen Co ri ht 23564 ' ' Trademark and hlps://- .walma/.com/global/seller/loz6 138 H.DIANJU Co ri ht 30 1 10 Happy Sky Golden Trademark and https://- .walmal4.coln/global/seller/loz7 139 Store Co ri ht 70 103 Trademark and lattpsr//- awalmal4.convglobal/sellel'/l 028 140 Heloow Co ri ht ' 98489 Trademark and hdps://- .walmart.coe global/seller/loz8 141 Hunter Genereux Co ri ht ' 47217 ' Trademark and https://- .walma/.com/global/seller/loz7 142 JI'NG HANG Co ri ht 20718 Trademarlt and lnttps://- .walnaal-t.com/global/sellel'/loz8 143 'in on li Co ri ht 49316 : Trademark and https://- .walma/.com/global/sellel'/loz8 144 Kan Wei Li Co ri ht 54828 . Tradelnark and https://- .wallrart.com/global/seller/loz8 145 li in Co riaht 49317 ' Tradelnark and https://- .walmal't.coe global/seller/loz7 146 MRLLRM Jewelr Co ri ht 48605 . Trademark and lAtps://- .walmal't.coo global/seller/loz; 147 MRLLRM MALL Co ri ht 48605 Trademark and llttps://- .wallAnaM.coe global/sellel'/loz8 148 Qilai Co., Ltd. Co ri ht 71633 road star happy goods Trademark and https://- .wallnnah.coo global/sellel'/l 029 149 o o Co ri ht 16970 Trademark and hûps://- .wallnal-t.coe global/sellel'/loz8 150 ShanYun Hua Co ri ht 62692 Trademark and https://- .walmart.coe global/sellel'/lozg 15 1 tunxuke'i on si Co ri ht 08453 Tradelnark and https://- .walmart.coln/global/sellel'/l 028 152 Wan izi Store Co ri ht 59460 Trademark and https://- ,walmal4.com/global/seller/lozg 153 Wu Xue Jin Co ri ht 2 1 108 ' Tradennark and https://- .waimal.com/global/sellel'/loz8 154 xian D Co ri ht 71240 xianyouxianyuegouse Trademark and https://- .walmal.coe global/seller/loz8 155 n Co ri ht 08760 xichengkejiyouxiang Trademark and lalps://- .walmad.com/global/sellel'/loz7 156 on si Co ri ht 89074 21 Case 1:25-cv-25486-FAM Document 28 Entered on FLSD Docket 05/22/2026 Page 21 of 22 . Trademarls and htps://- .walmart.coe global/seller/loz; 1$7 XUAWWSFF (to ri ht . 90013 158 DISMISSED . Yiju Intelligent Trademark and hlps://v .walmal.com/global/seller/loz8 159 . E ui ment Co Co ri ht ' 71366 ' Trademark and https://- .walmàd.coe global/seller/loz8 160 ZhiHua Ma Co ri ht . 22494 Trademark and https://- .walmad.coe global/seller/loz8 161 . Zhon Qin Zhao' Co ri V 48474 Trademark and htps://- .wish.com/merchant/6oel4osg3 162 Döroth Featured Co ri ht 2t3 1a67cacc0e1e' . ' Case 1:25-cv-25486-FAM Document 28 Entered on FLSD Docket 05/22/2026 Page 22 of 22